Easiest choice in the world for me.
On one hand you have a beautiful, life affirming story about a man waking from his mid-life crisis and just going about it the wrong way. In hindsight Kevin Spacey's last scene, as he understand what truly makes him happy, is both gorgeous and heartbreaking in it's tragedy. Nothing I say really does the film justice, it's a film that has to be seen for the quality of the performances.
On the other hand, you have the boring LotR's film. Walk a lot, talk a bit, fight a bit, it's a setup film where not much happens and it really isn't that entertaining in comparison to the 2 films that followed it. Gollum was always the most interesting thing in the 3 films and the lack of his presence is noticeable.