Ballpark Brawl
Natural Heavyweight Championship (1 time)1[79]
Extreme Wrestling Federation
Xtreme 8 Tournament (2006)[80]
Independent Wrestling Association Mid-South
Revolution Strong Style Tournament (2004)[2]
Pro Wrestling Illustrated
PWI ranked him #4 of the 500 best singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 2006 and 2008[81]
PWI Feud of the Year (2007)[82] vs. Kurt Angle
PWI Most Popular Wrestler of the Year (2006)[83]
Pro Wrestling Zero1-Max
NWA Intercontinental Tag Team Championship (1 time)2[13][14] – with Keiji Sakoda
Pure Wrestling Association
PWA Pure Wrestling Championship (1 time)[2]
Ring of Honor
ROH Pure Championship (1 time)[19][20]
ROH World Championship (1 time)[17][18]
SoCal Uncensored
Rookie of the Year (2000)[84]
Total Nonstop Action Wrestling
TNA World Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[29]
TNA World Tag Team Championship (1 time)3[29]
TNA X Division Championship (4 times)[29]
King of the Mountain (2008) [45]
Super X Cup (2005)
Turkey Bowl (2007)
Triple Crown Champion (1 time)
Mr. TNA (2006)[85]
Mr. X Division (2006)[85]
Feud of the Year (2006) with Kurt Angle[85]
Twin Wrestling Entertainment
TWE Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[2]
Ultimate Pro Wrestling
UPW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[86]
UPW No Hold Barred Championship (2 times)[86]
United Independent Wrestling Alliance
UIWA Tag Team Championship (2 times)[2]
Wrestling Observer Newsletter awards
5 Star Match (2004) vs. CM Punk at ROH Joe vs. Punk II on October 16
5 Star Match (2005) vs. AJ Styles and Christopher Daniels at TNA Unbreakable on September 11
5 Star Match (2005) vs. Kenta Kobashi at ROH Joe vs. Kobashi on October 1
Match of the Year (2005) vs. Kenta Kobashi, ROH Joe vs. Kobashi, October 1
Most Outstanding Wrestler (2005)